By Connie Leinbach
New research by author-historian Kevin Duffus of Raleigh has revealed that the positive identification of an African-American member of Blackbeard’s crew provides evidence to the infamous pirate’s identity and origin.
Contrary to popular myth, Caesar, who was one of six African-American slaves in Blackbeard’s crew, survived well beyond the rest of the crew, said Duffus, author of “The Last Days of Black Beard the Pirate,” which sifts through the myths and facts about arguably the most famous pirate ever.
Duffus, who was named North Carolina Historian of the Year by the North Carolina Society of Historians on Oct. 25, will present two talks about his recent findings during the Second Annual Blackbeard’s Pirate Jamboree here this weekend Oct. 31 to Nov. 2.
One of Blackbeard’s trusted mates, Caesar’s own myth has grown through the centuries. For example, an island in the Florida keys is named for him and Caesar has his own Wikipedia page.
Caesar’s alleged duty aboard the ill-fated Adventure at Ocracoke was to blow up the boat if the pirates were losing the battle with Lt. Robert Maynard. But Caesar did not execute that command.
“In the popular legend, Caesar was then hanged in Williamsburg, Va., but I have found proof that he was alive a year later in the town of Bath,” Duffus said in a recent interview.
Duffus can prove that Caesar was present in Bath in 1716, two years before Blackbeard’s end on Ocracoke Nov. 22, 1718.
A few pirates were hanged in Hampton, Va., (for crime of firing guns against the flag of the king of England) but Caesar was not among those.
“I can prove Caesar was alive and well in 1719,” Duffus said. “It’s remarkable that a black slave can be found in the record to support my theory of who Blackbeard was.”
Caesar and other young men, including Blackbeard, were residents of Bath, and Duffus said Caesar was owned by Blackbeard’s mentor and advisor Tobias Knight.
“I think Caesar was Tobias Knight’s investment in Blackbeard’s enterprises,” Duffus said.
What prompted these young men to take off in July 1716 and become “pirates” was the wreck of a Spanish treasure fleet off the central coast of Florida.
“Eleven Spanish ships were heavily laden with gold,” Duffus said. “There are records of young men who left for Florida and could walk onto the beach and scoop up armfuls of gold.”
Although it’s unknown whether Blackbeard and his crew left for that purpose, Duffus said that the names of the best-known pirates in history are not in the records prior to this wreck.
“Then they start appearing in the record,” he said.
It was, in effect, a gold rush.
“I think their beginnings were innocent, but once acts of piracy were being committed it produced a mob mentality—like looting nowadays,” Duffus said. “That’s why, when they came back to North Carolina, a number of them tried to live honest lives.”
Duffus makes a case for this in his story behind a watercolor painting of Blackbeard and his crew he commissioned titled “The Return of the Pamlico River Pirates” that shows Blackbeard’s hand resting on Caesar’s shoulder.
“Until now this historical truth has been eclipsed by the colossal legend of popular culture’s fictional version of Black Beard, leading generations to believe that these men were ruthless, bloodthirsty criminals. Many of these men were the sons, or in some instances, slaves, of Pamlico-area plantation owners. These Pamlico River mariners and their slaves, led by the tall, charismatic Edward “Black” Beard, strayed across the boundaries of lawfulness no more than anyone else in colonial America at the time, including Governors, customs officials and ministers. Everyone simply did what they had to do to survive.”
Posters and high-quality, limited edition prints of the painting will be for sale during the jamboree.
Duffus’s book has been revised with the addition of two chapters devoted to his findings on Caesar. It is available in shops throughout the island.
“Caesar is the earliest notable African-American resident of North Carolina,” he said.
Duffus will dispel myths about Blackbeard at 7 p.m. Friday, Oct. 31, in the Community Center and at 1 p.m. on Saturday, Nov. 2, at the Books to be Red Stage.
Those who can’t attend the Jamboree can inquire about purchasing prints or posters by contacting Looking_glass@earthlink.net.
Duffus also will lead the Blackbeard memorial Sunday morning at Springer’s Point. The march begins at Blackbeard’s Lodge along Back Road, continues along Irvin Garrish Highway to Lighthouse Road.
Lunch with the pirates at Howard’s Pub will follow at noon.
For details on all of the weekend activities, visit http://www.piratejamboree.com
This story first appeared in the November 2014 print edition of the Ocracoke Observer.