Text and photos by Kevin Duffus
The phenomenon is unique to the shores of the East Coast–the many legends of Blackbeard’s buried treasure.
Just a few of the far-flung places where the notorious pirate is said to have deposited his loot include the Cayman Islands; Lynnhaven Bay, Mulberry Island, or Tangier Island, Virginia; Trenton, New Jersey; Blackbeard Island, Georgia; and Lunging Island, New Hampshire.
In North Carolina he is believed to have buried his treasure on Money Island near Cape Fear, Ocracoke Island, Buxton Woods, the Pasquotank River, Bath Creek and under a tree near Oriental.
Then, if anyone, anywhere on the U.S. East Coast, the Bahamas or the West Indies finds a handful of buried old coins, voilà! They’ve found Blackbeard’s treasure.
For a man who, as official documents confirm, was a pirate for just 23 months, he must have spent nearly all of that time digging holes.
I don’t put much credence on Blackbeard treasure stories, except for maybe this one.
In early June 1938, Dallas Jordan, 64, a black farmer and owner of a 10-acre tract of cotton, corn, and tobacco along the west bank of the Pungo River, walked into Stewart’s Jewelry Store in “little” Washington with two chunks of gold that were plowed up by his wife’s nephew, Edward Connie.
A newspaper account estimated that the amount of gold was “big enough to fill half the dental cavities in Eastern North Carolina.”
The gold was only a small portion of what Connie had unearthed. The jeweler examined it and concluded that its porous quality suggested that the gold had perhaps been inexpertly melted down from coins or jewelry.
He assayed the dirty lumps of gold to about 20 carats. He offered Mr. Jordan $300, who smiled and left. Three more much larger gold ingots were hidden back at his home.
Since 1933, because of the Great Depression, the government had outlawed the hoarding of gold.
The trustworthy owner of a general store near Jordan’s farm advised the lucky man to “get to the mint as quickly as possible and keep mum as a clam.”
Two weeks later in the middle of the night, Jordan, accompanied by his son and a hired driver who owned a good car, quietly drove down the rutted dirt road from his little farm and headed to “big” Washington to meet with the feds at the U.S. Mint.
On a seat next to Jordan was a discretely wrapped bundle containing the heavy gold bars.
Jordan knew bits of the Blackbeard legend–that the pirate was purported to have lived in Bath just 11 miles west of his farm and had frequented the Pamlico and Pungo rivers.
He wondered if he had found the pirate’s treasure.
“DID PLOWMAN BLUNDER ON SECRET BLACKBEARD BOASTED ONLY HE AND THE DEVIL KNEW?”
That was the headline in a newspaper referring to the widely known legend, that on the night before his ill-fated battle with the Royal Navy at Ocracoke, one of Blackbeard’s shipmates asked him if his latest wife knew where he had buried his treasure in the event that things would go badly.
Blackbeard’s answer: “That no Body but himself and the Devil knew where it was and the longest Liver should take all.”
Blackbeard hadn’t figured that Edward Connie of Beaufort County, North Carolina, would find it—if it was indeed the pirate’s treasure.
“Naw, I didn’t know it was gold. Not right at first,” said Connie, quoted by the Raleigh News & Observer.
Two weeks later and eight-and-a-half hours after leaving Belhaven in the dark of night, Jordan walked into the U.S. Mint at Washington, D.C., and was greeted by a U.S. Secret Service investigator.
Three solid gold ingots were examined. Jordan’s deposition under oath was recorded, and by 4 p.m., with an official U.S. Treasury receipt in hand, the formerly poor black farmer was on his way back to North Carolina thinking about how he was going to spend his new fortune.
A week later, a U.S. Secret Service agent showed up at the Jordan farm, soon followed by a reporter from Raleigh.
Although it wasn’t reported, it is assumed that the government man was there to hand Jordan an envelope containing a Treasury check, estimated to be about $2,000. Rumors followed that the gold was really worth as much as $15,000, but Jordan said the rumors were false.
In today’s value, Jordan’s gold was worth $47,360. The agent advised the elderly farmer to keep quiet and say “no” to all salesmen who would surely seek him out.
Jordan was an astute and sensible man. He planned to use the money to paint and make repairs to his house that had been damaged in a storm and to rebuild a porch on which he could enjoy his twilight years.
But could Dallas Jordan’s gold bars have been pirate treasure? Maybe.
Here’s my analysis.
As for facts, the news reports from the 1930s lacked any information about the Secret Service’s analysis of the gold ingots—no estimate of the age of the gold, no reference to assayer’s marks, foundry registry numbers, or tax cartouche stamps that would have been punched on all the bars had they come from Spanish America.
If the gold was of Spanish origin, the likelihood that it was piratically acquired would have increased exponentially.
Regrettably, there are no published photos of the gold bars.
A reporter wrote, “The Secret Service doesn’t answer questions, even if it had the answers about who buried gold.”
However, now with the passage of time, perhaps the Treasury Department would be more forthcoming.
While early settlers were known to bury ceramic pots filled with coins for safekeeping, gold bars would have been an extremely rare possession for anyone living along the Pamlico and Pungo rivers in the 18th century—or ever.
Was it Civil War treasure?
Jordan was quoted as having recalled a story about a local resident who buried his valuables upon hearing that the Yankees were coming, but other county history authorities discounted a Civil War connection.
Which brings us back to pirates.
It is well-documented that Blackbeard’s crew, as well as other pirates, frequented the site on the Florida coast where 11 Spanish treasure ships were wrecked in a hurricane in July 1715.
There was a substantial amount of silver and smaller amounts of gold in bars and jewelry lost in the shallow water of the wrecks—some of which is, remarkably, still being recovered to this day.
I have previously written that that was how “the boys from Bath” eventually became pirates—they set out from the Pamlico River in 1716 intending to be wreckers or salvagers of Spanish treasure.
It wasn’t as easy as they were led to believe.
That Blackbeard and his cohort of 100s of pirates were known to have “fished” the Florida wrecks whenever they were passing by and that they also later passed the mouth of the Pungo River a few times while traveling between Ocracoke and Bath provides some reason to believe that Dallas Jordan’s ingots might have been piratically obtained.
The location of the gold on Jordan’s farm alongside a navigable body of water further suggests that the treasure likely arrived by boat.
Perhaps the gold belonged to mariner Stephen Elsey, who, approximately two weeks after Blackbeard’s arrival at Bath in the summer of 1718, purchased from John Worley Esq., a 188-acre property east of Bath for the payment of “two male negro slaves called Pamptico and Pungo.” The property included “14 head of cows and cow beasts, 4 horses, and 20 bushels of corn.”
Since Elsey was a newcomer to Bath and was in possession of slaves, he may have been a member of Blackbeard’s “Queen Anne’s Revenge” company.
Two months later, Elsey and another suspected pirate, James Robins, bought Governor Eden’s former 400-acre plantation on Bath Creek in exchange for three enslaved men.
Or maybe Blackbeard’s quartermaster, William Howard, buried the gold.
His father, Philip Howard, also owned a 320-acre plantation between Bath and the Pungo River. The younger Howard was nearly hanged in Virginia but was saved at the last minute by the arrival of a pardon from George I.
By 1730, Howard inherited his father’s property but sold it along with a five-acre tract, again somewhere near the Pungo River.
Or perhaps the gold belonged to one of the more than 25 other pirates from the “Queen Anne’s Revenge” who came to Bath with Blackbeard and were never named in the official records.
But why was the gold never recovered by whoever buried it in the first place? Unless whoever buried it died or was killed before they could return to reclaim it.
This is why I believe it is not unreasonable to suspect that the gold was, indeed, Blackbeard’s.
On one hand, it is hard to imagine how and when the notorious pirate captain could have slipped off unnoticed by dozens of his fellow pirates and buried the gold bars.
But had he been able to do so, his four enslaved servants, James Blake, Thomas Gates, James White and Richard Stiles, were surely with him to dig the requisite hole.
Records show that the pirate captain and his four servants were alone for 36 hours over the night of September 14, 1718, when they journeyed from Ocracoke to Bath and back for a secret midnight meeting with the colony’s Collector of Customs—and Blackbeard’s business partner—Tobias Knight.
Sadly, all four black men were arrested after their boss was killed at the Battle of Ocracoke and were hanged at Hampton, Virginia.
Consequently, the only men who knew where the gold was buried—Blackbeard, Blake, Gates, White, and Stiles—were dead.
And so, the treasure’s location remained unknown for 220 years.
Historians often like to imagine, what if?
What if Dallas Jordan, serendipitously, turned out to be a descendant of one of Blackbeard’s enslaved servants or any one of the 60 enslaved black men who were brought to the Pamlico River and Bath town by the pirates in 1718? It is entirely possible.
That would be poetic justice.
Kevin Duffus is an award-winning North Carolina historian, filmmaker, and author of 10 books whose research focuses on the state’s maritime and coastal history.








